By Carlos Ball, editor of AIPE, a Spanish-language news organization
based in Florida, and an adjunct scholar at the Cato
Institute.
The Venezuelan political elite was dealt a heavy blow in
December when
the country elected the anti-establishment Hugo Chávez
as president with
56% of the vote.
Mr. Chávez's policies are still in formation, but what
is clear is that without
the election of an outsider the traditional power
brokers who have done so
much damage to the country would have continued
unchecked. As
example, consider the last two presidents, Carlos Andres
Pérez and Rafael
Caldera, who were like characters out of the 1958 novel
"The Leopard" by
Prince Lampedusa, which portrayed a decadent Sicilian
aristocracy that
made changes only in order to ensure that everything
remained the same.
During Venezuela's 41-year democracy -- since the end of
the military
dictatorship in 1958 -- the country had two main
political parties -- the
social-democrats' Democratic Action (AD) and the
Christian-Democrats
(Copei). They not only alternated in power but also
entered into a famous
power-sharing agreement called "Pacto de Punto Fijo" --
named for the
home of Mr. Caldera -- in order to crush any political
competition.
If there were some policy differences between them
initially, these became
increasingly less noticeable as their nomenklatura
extended its tentacles over
every aspect of daily life. They controlled Congress,
the judiciary, the civil
service, labor unions, professional associations, the
universities and even the
armed forces. Theirs was a dynasty that seemed untouchable.
But Mr. Chávez is challenging all that. He ran on an
anti-establishment
platform backed by a coalition called Patriotic Pole.
And when he was
sworn in as president on Feb. 2 he took an untraditional
oath: "I swear
before God, before the Fatherland, before my people, and
before this dying
constitution, to fulfill the necessary democratic
transformations in order for
the Republic to have a new constitution, suited to the
new times."
The AD and Copei congressmen who are now beating their
breasts in
defense of the existing constitution are the same ones
who, through their
political parties, colluded in order to suspend -- for
30 years -- specific
constitutional clauses that protected private property
and free enterprise.
The reason was simple: It was the only way they could
control the economy
and make lucrative deals with mercantilists. Mr.
Chavez's rise to power
threatens years of "investments" made by these
politicians and their
associates in the business community.
The judicial system was destroyed by the AD-Copei
establishment. During
the old military dictatorships, judges had been
appointed on the strength of
their professional credentials. But in 1969 AD changed
the law so that
judges would be chosen by party affiliation, in
proportion to the electoral
results. The outcome was the near-disappearance of the
rule of law. Today
political contacts or deep pockets win in court. The
poor, who cannot
afford lawyers with the right contacts, often languish
in jail for years without
hope of trial.
Mr. Chávez's mother prayed he would become a priest, but
he preferred
the military and in 1992 headed an unsuccessful coup
against President
Carlos Andrés Pérez. Last year he campaigned against the
corrupt
establishment, which has bankrupted a rich and
prosperous nation. Critics
like to say he is a radical but the facts support his
case: In the past quarter
century, the public payroll increased to 1.3 million
from 484,000. Salaries
have been financed by inflating the local currency, the
bolivar. Today it
takes 578 bolivars to buy one U.S. dollar, compared to
4.30 bolivars in
1983; that is a 13,340% devaluation. Per capita income
has backtracked to
1952 levels; 80% of Venezuelans now live in poverty.
The recent sharp drop in oil prices has revealed an
economy with no
clothes. Suddenly, with AD and Copei left without enough
money to buy
votes, a clean election brought in Mr. Chávez.
His popularity is boundless among the poor and a
shrinking middle class
that has seen its standard of living drop year after
year. They are sick of
hearing the same old political discourse and neither
group has much to lose.
Don't talk macroeconomics, or about the fact that the
Venezuelan
government owns Citgo, the largest gas retailer in the
U.S., with the average
dweller of a shantytown on Caracas' hillside. He doesn't
have running water
and must pay protection to the local gang because the
police are busy
serving as bodyguards to politicians and bureaucrats.
Even after former President Jaime Lusinchi was living in
Miami, 36 agents of
the political police remained assigned in Caracas as his
full-time
bodyguards. In one of his first acts as president, Mr.
Chávez fired all of
them, as well as the heads of all the country's corrupt
customs offices. His
first electoral promise was personal security for the
common people.
Some political analysts have concluded that Mr. Chávez
is a combination of
a Marxist and an old-style Latin-American populist. He
certainly has
surrounded himself with old socialists. But despite the
hero's welcome to
Cuba that Castro gave him in 1994, it's hard to believe
he would want to
identify himself with a failed ideology. He undoubtedly
is a nationalist and a
patriot. His economics are obscure, to say the least,
but what else is new
with politicians from the Hudson Bay to Cape Horn?
Moreover, while he admits to only a rudimentary
understanding of
economics he has already learned the basics better than
his predecessors.
Labor unions controlled by AD are demanding
government-mandated price
controls and across-the-board salary increases for the
private sector. Mr.
Chávez has refused. Who, then, is practicing populism,
the old
establishment or the new president?
The proposed constitution also worries many Venezuelans.
It is true that the
new Colombian and Brazilian constitutions are much worse
that the ones
they replaced. And those close to Mr. Chávez seem
determined to come up
with a new document packed with political wishes. But by
the same token,
what Venezuela has now hardly passes for a democracy.
Mr. Chávez is already at odds with the Congress, which
remains rife with
AD and Copei dinosaurs, and he may view a new
constitution as the only
way to fight them. He is also streamlining government by
reducing the
number of cabinet ministries from 24 to 14.
Venezuela has a long way to go. Class-warfare rhetoric
is in vogue, and
some of the old mercantilists did finance the Chávez
campaign, presumably
not without motive. But the new president is intelligent
and wants the best
for his country. This is just the beginning of the
story, and those who claim
to know the end are lying.
Copyright © 1999 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All
Rights Reserved.
|